Invisibility cloaking or cloaking devices refer to a piece of garment or a device that can render a human being utterly invisible to the naked eye. Although invisibility cloaks seem like a concept of science fiction, they are now a reality. These cloaks can now be built by employing carefully designed nanostructures (or metamaterials). However, these metamaterial cloaking devices might not be as we are told to imagine by the movies (not yet anyway). To understand the mechanism and operation of current technologies in metamaterial cloaking, we need to understand a few things beforehand.

Prior knowledge on how cloaking works? And what makes something invisible?

Human beings operate on their senses. We have five basic senses, which are touch, hearing, smell, taste, and sight. We see the objects when incident light on an object is reflected into our eyes. This light is captured by RGB (Reg-Green-Blue) color-sensitive cones in our eyes. These colors are finally decoded into an image by our brain. Sometimes we see objects that are transmitting light, such as glass and plastic. These objects transmit more light than they are reflecting, which is why we can see things present behind them. Inherently these objects lay down the basics of cloaking devices. An example would be people walking to glass doors and hitting them as they don’t realize the presence of a glass door because it was so clear.

Now we know what a cloaking material would look like. This material should be transparent and should reflect a negligible amount of light. After understanding the material properties, we need to understand the behavior of light. Basically, all light is an Electromagnetic (EM) wave, and we can observe only a tiny spectrum (visible spectrum) through our eyes. Conservatively speaking, this range lies around ~400-700 nm. This is just like the frequency of sounds human beings can hear, around 20 Hz-20 kHz. Back to our discussion, if we have a material that is completely transmitting a higher wavelength but blocking the visible spectrum, our eyes will see it as an object. Still, for that specific wavelength, which we cannot see, that object is a transmitter. This is the current technology of metamaterial cloaking, cloaks for higher wavelength.

Finally, we can discuss ways to conceal the objects. Glasses and plastics do not conceal anything as they transmit the light to objects in the background, as shown in Fig. 1. Therefore, they are not suitable. We need something that does not allow us to see an object immediately behind the cloak but lets us see an object far behind in the background. One might think that a way to render the object invisible could be to completely absorb the light falling on the cloaking device. However, this would create a black spot as all light is being absorbed (given in Fig. 1). This is the basic idea behind thermal cloaking, which requires a perfect absorber to absorb all electromagnetic waves for a narrow or broadband spectrum. To achieve cloaking in its true sense, the light needs to bend around the object and be received at the other end in its original form. This is the basic idea involved in the working of metamaterial cloaking. The two established ways through which metamaterial cloaking is achieved are explained in the following sections.

A depiction of cloaking.
Figure 1: A depiction of cloaking.

Transmission based metamaterial cloaking

The transmission-based cloaking was first explored for the microwave regime. This research was conducted in collaboration by Professor Sir John Brian Pendry of Imperial College of London and Professor David R. Smith of Duke University1. This metamaterial cloaking device o operated at a frequency of 8.5 GHz. It was developed using 10 concentric cylinders of multiple metamaterial unit elements. The metamaterial cloak was designed using coordinate transformation, which compresses a cylindrical region into an annular region. The propagation direction was selected to be the z-axis, and this resulted in the following equations.

\[\epsilon_z=\left( \begin{array}{cc|r} \frac{b}{b-a} \end{array} \right)^2\] \[\mu_r=\left( \begin{array}{cc|r} \frac{r-a}{r} \end{array} \right)^2\] \[\mu_o=1\]

Here the terms a and b represent the inner and outer radius of metamaterial cloaking design as a whole, and r represents the radius. The a and b for the design were selected to be 27.1 mm and 58.9 mm, respectively. The terms εz and μo remain constant, and depending on the values of μr, the response from individual metamaterials can be varied. This variation in μr yields different refractive index for metamaterial unit elements presents in the different cylindrical arrays.

The design behaves in such a way that it does not allow any EM wave at 8.5 GHz to pass from the inner cylinder, thereby rendering any object inside the inner cylinder completely invisible. Although this invisibility is not as per our imagination, the hidden object is utterly invisible to 8.5 GHz detectors since no EM wave of 8.5 GHz passes through them. This lack of EM waves ultimately puts reflection, transmission, or absorption from hidden objects out of the question. To test the metamaterial cloaking design, the team used a metallic sphere (considered to be the objects providing the highest scattering) inside the fabricated metamaterial cloak design. The measured results suggested very minute scattering (reflection) because of the simplification of the design model. Transmission-based metamaterial cloaking is depicted in Fig. 2.

Transmission-based and reflection-based metamaterial cloaking.

Reflection based metamaterial cloaking

The reflection-based metamaterial cloaking also works on the principles of transformation optics2. The reflection-based metamaterial cloaking device consists of slanting metamaterial unit elements and a perfect electric conductor (PEC) ground plane. The region between the metamaterial cloak and PEC (metal) will be the cloaked area. Reflection-based cloaks reflect the incident wave when it hits instead of transmitting it, which happens in transmission-based metamaterial cloaking devices. The metamaterial elements compensate for the phase shifts that might occur due to object/s inside the cloaked area. When the wave leaves the opposite end, it will be in its original form, undistorted by the object present inside the “bump”3(cloaked area).

The primary benefit of this sort of design is that the cloaked area can include any type of object. The reflection-based metamaterial cloak designs can also be made tunable2. Therefore, this design scheme is independent of the shape and size of the object it is meant to conceal. However, there is a stringent condition of wave incidence angle for which this reflection metamaterial cloaking operates. A depiction of reflection-based metamaterial cloaking is provided in Fig. 2.

Both of these methods have pros and cons, so choosing the best scheme for cloaking is subjective. Moreover, the designs still operate for microwave (GHz) or terahertz (THz) regimes, and optical cloaking in visible regime is still not yet realized. However, by these proofs of concept, broadband visible light cloaking must not be far behind. We will stay optimistic about it.

Optimism is the faith that leads to achievement. Nothing can be done without hope and confidence.

Helen Keller

References

  1. Schurig, D., Mock, J. J., Justice, B. J., Cummer, S. A., Pendry, J. B., Starr, A. F., & Smith, D. R. (2006). Metamaterial electromagnetic cloak at microwave frequencies. Science, 314(5801), 977-980.
  2. Shin, D., Urzhumov, Y., Jung, Y., Kang, G., Baek, S., Choi, M., … & Smith, D. R. (2012). Broadband electromagnetic cloaking with smart metamaterials. Nature communications3(1), 1-8.
  3. Yang, Y., Jing, L., Zheng, B., Hao, R., Yin, W., Li, E., … & Chen, H. (2016). Full‐polarization 3D metasurface cloak with preserved amplitude and phase. Advanced Materials28(32), 6866-6871.

Further readings

If you liked reading this post, you might be interested in reading the following posts.

  • Scattering of light and its different types
    The general meaning of the word “scattering” Scattering, in a general sense, relates to the change in the direction of an object in motion after it collides with another. Sometimes, the scattering also defines dispersing of objects when they encounter some obstacle. Interpretation of scattering in physics Similar to the
  • The achromatic lens to remove chromatic aberration
    What is an achromatic aberration? A chromatic aberration is the inability of a lens to focus different wavelengths on a single focal point. This phenomenon happens because of the fact that the refractive index of a material depends on the wavelength. That is why materials are called dispersive, meaning their
  • Wave plates and polarizers for polarization manipulation
    Introduction to wave plates “Wave plate is an instrument (Optical device) that has the ability to change the state of light when light is incident on it.” These plates are made from different materials most common of which are birefringent material (plastic) Wave plates either half or quarter plates have
  • Birefringence and birefringent materials
    Crystals are categorized as both isotropic and anisotropic depending upon their optical behavior and whether or not their crystallographic axes are equivalent. All isotropic crystals have identical axes that similarly engage with light, irrespective of the crystal orientation with admire to incident light waves. Light getting into an isotropic crystal is refracted at a regular attitude and passes through the crystal at a fixed angle, having constant speed without being polarized with the aid of interaction with the electronic components of the crystalline lattice. On the other
  • Refractive Index Calculator both simple and complex
    Inroduction to refractive index calculator The refractive index describes the change in speed of light as it enters from air into the material under observation. Therefore, the refractive index is a material property and everything we see around in our daily lives is composed of different materials. All of the
  • Blackbody radiation calculator for specific wavelengths and temperatures
    What is blackbody radiation? Any object that is composed of subatomic particles emits electromagnetic (EM) radiations when it is above the absolute temperature of 0o Kelvins (which corresponds to approximately -273.15o K). This emission of EM waves is termed thermal radiation and it represents the internal energy converted by the
  • Electromagnetic spectrum and corresponding applications of electromagnetic waves
    Introduction to Electromagnetic waves and electromagnetic spectrum Waves are categorized into three main types, mechanical, electromagnetic, and matter waves. The waves that can pass through a medium are called mechanical waves. Whereas, electromagnetic waves (EM Waves), a special type of wave, do not require a medium to travel or propagate.
  • Types of mirrors and their applications in everyday life
    A mirror is a reflecting surface that reflects light excellently and does not allow it to refract, producing a clear image. It produces either real or virtual images. A famous German chemist Justus made mirrors commercially available in 1835. He made the mirror by coating a thin layer of silver
  • Description of lens and its different types with their applications
    Related Terms of Lenses Before discussing lens and their properties and application, one should be familiar with these terms. Refractive Index Refractive index is a ratio of the speed of light when it passes through the vacuum to its values when it passes through a specific medium. where c is
  • How do we see colors? The human eye and its functioning
    The human brain and the human eye cooperatively translate light into color. Light receptors are present in the eye, which transmits the messages to the brain. These light receptors are present within the human eye to produce the confidential sensation of colors. Newton perceives that color is not inherent in

Leave a Reply

We encourage your valuable feedback.

Your email address will not be published.